Weekly wisdom episode 70

Training Fragility: When Fitness Trackers Do More Harm Than Good

November 20, 2026•8 min read

Weekly Wisdom #70

“Wearable-induced anxiety happens when constant access to biometric data—like heart rate, sleep scores, and stress alerts from smartwatches or fitness trackers—triggers obsession, hypervigilance, and health worry rather than reassurance.” — Gemini

We have more information available to us than at any time in history. And we’re more anxious and less healthy than ever.

Look, if you use wearables and love them, you do you. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. But if your wearable is causing you stress, or if you don’t have a wearable and wonder if you should, this post is for you.

This post was inspired by Mr. Fantastic’s recent talk at Empower Every Body Fitness in Vancouver, in which he discussed the subject in depth. He owns every major wearable device out there and has tested them in the laboratory against medical-grade monitors. The results weren’t very reassuring.

When Tracking Your Sleep Keeps You Awake

One of the popular uses of wearables these days is measuring sleep scores to tell you how well you have slept. There is a phenomenon associated with the rise in sleep trackers called orthosomnia. People become so worried about their sleep scores that they cannot sleep.

Really, it’s a thing. Look it up.

Tested in a sleep lab against medical-grade monitoring of sleep cycles, the various sleep trackers produced results that Mr. Fantastic compared to “random number generators.” None of the devices he tested produced consistently accurate results. And if you wore three different trackers, they would give you three different scores.

Same goes for heart rate variability (HRV). Athletes are using HRV readings to determine how hard they should train on any given day. Unfortunately for them, the data can be hit and miss.

The best determinant of how hard you should train? How your body feels.

Moral of the story: don’t listen to your tracker over your body.

Of course, what begins to happen is that if we believe our tracker, we begin to manifest the feelings that its score tells us we should have.

Maybe you wake up feeling great but make the mistake of looking down at your tracker, which informs you that your HRV is low and that you are in the red. You should take it easy today.

Suddenly, you don’t feel so good, so you decide to go easy. Maybe take the day off.

Squatting to a target

Heart Rate Zones: Are You Training by the Numbers?

Then there are the good old heart rate monitors used to tell you what training zone you are in.

The problem? Wrist-based heart rate monitors can be considerably less accurate than chest straps, particularly during certain types of exercise. Even with a chest strap, the number displayed may reflect some averaging and processing rather than your exact heart rate at that instant. Research into wearable heart rate monitoring highlights the limitations of relying on these devices.

The combination of lag time and averaging can result in a scenario where you are doubled over, gasping from exertion, heart in your throat, while your device provides a heart rate readout that suggests you are still at rest.

And here’s another thing about heart rate zones while we’re on the topic.

You know that old 220 minus your age calculation people use to determine maximum heart rate?

Well, it’s not wrong, but the problem with it is that it’s based on population averages. Which works really well at the population level. But you cannot reliably extrapolate from a population average to an individual.

For example, knowing that the average life expectancy of a woman in Vancouver is 86.5 years tells you next to nothing about how long you, personally, are going to live. You cannot use that calculation to plan your life.

Similarly, 220 minus your age doesn’t do a fantastic job of telling us your maximum heart rate.

This is why many coaches, including those of us coaching CrossFit and functional fitness, use RPE, or rate of perceived exertion, to help guide training intensity.

RPE is a way of measuring how hard an exercise feels rather than relying exclusively on a number generated by a device. It takes into account something your watch cannot fully capture: your actual experience of the effort.

And that matters, whether you are a competitive athlete or someone in their 50s working to build strength, improve fitness, and stay healthy as they age.

Continuous Glucose Monitors: More Data, Better Health?

Continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) have also become popular. I have tested them myself. And while they are essential tools for managing certain medical conditions, their utility for the average healthy person is dubious.

Mine, for example, would wake me up in the middle of the night, the alarm sounding because my blood glucose levels had dropped below the safe threshold, triggering a health alert.

Did I wake feeling dizzy, faint, weak?

No. Despite the alarming blood sugar readings, I felt fine.

Was the reading accurate? Was it a false low caused by pressure on the sensor while I slept? Without confirming it, I had no way of knowing.

Is there some information to be gleaned from wearing a continuous glucose monitor? Yes. It was an interesting experiment.

But over the long term, I tend to agree with Mr. Fantastic’s assessment that it is not the minor daily fluctuations that impact your health so much as longer-term patterns of blood glucose regulation.

Using a blood glucose monitor to track your daily peaks and valleys and extrapolating those patterns to your overall health is a bit like checking your RRSP portfolio every thirty minutes to assess the long-term viability of your investments.

There is little value in it. In fact, it may lead to more harm than benefit if you start making unnecessary changes in response to every fluctuation.

Trying to correct for perfectly normal daily variations may distract you from the habits that actually support long-term health.

Kettlebell row at Empower

When Health Optimization Becomes an Obsession

Tech billionaire Bryan Johnson, who has spent millions trying to biohack his health, is a case in point.

Recently, Bryan was diagnosed with autoimmune gastritis, a chronic condition. Whether his extensive health interventions contributed to it is unclear, but the irony is difficult to miss: even someone devoting extraordinary resources to controlling every aspect of his health cannot eliminate illness.

And this is the real danger of these devices.

In our obsession with perfection, we start chasing numbers on a screen instead of listening to our bodies.

As Mr. Fantastic pointed out, the one thing the longest-lived people in the world seem to have in common is that they don’t obsess about their health.

Yes, they tend to lead active lives and enjoy diets built around whole, unprocessed foods. They are active in their communities and get outside a lot. Movement is a natural part of their daily lives.

But they are not intermittent fasting, sleeping in hyperbaric chambers, competing in marathons, obsessing about body fat percentages, or trying to optimize every external health factor.

Some of them drink a bit, smoke a bit, indulge a bit.

And without a billion dollars or any biohacking, many of them will outlive Bryan Johnson. Not only in years, but potentially in the quality of those years too.

That distinction matters.

We talk a lot about longevity, but what we really want is health span: the years of our lives spent healthy, capable, independent, and able to do the things we enjoy.

Strength training, regular physical activity, good nutrition, meaningful relationships, and a sense of community all contribute to that goal. None requires us to obsess over a daily readiness score.

When 200 Steps Become More Important Than Common Sense

Mr. Fantastic shared an anecdote pertaining to step counters.

He ran into a man walking in a terrible rainstorm in the cold and damp, determined to get those last 200 steps in because he needed to meet his quota.

As if falling a few steps shy of the daily goal was more detrimental to his health than being outside wet and shivering in stormy conditions.

Walking is healthy. More walking is generally better. But where did 8,000 steps per day or 10,000 steps per day come from?

The famous 10,000-step target originated as a marketing concept for a Japanese pedometer, not as a scientifically established threshold for good health. Subsequent research has demonstrated benefits from increasing daily steps, but there is no magical number at which walking suddenly becomes healthy.

And do these guidelines mean that you fail if you only got in 5,000 steps today?

Of course not.

Yet that is exactly how we begin to think when we allow a device to define success or failure.

The same problem can creep into strength training and functional fitness. We can become so preoccupied with hitting prescribed numbers, whether they are heart rate zones, training loads, or recovery scores, that we lose sight of what the training is supposed to accomplish.

The goal is to become stronger, fitter, healthier, and more resilient. Not to earn the approval of a smartwatch.

Are We Training Fitness or Training Fragility?

At the end of the day, we need to remember that tools serve us.

Use wearables if you want, but do not fall into the trap of living to serve the tool.

A lot of these target numbers are generalizations at best or guesses at worst. Some may serve as useful guidelines sometimes, so long as you do not become a slave to them. Others are completely arbitrary, made-up numbers.

Good coaching works much the same way. We use measurements, benchmarks, and training plans to guide our decisions, but we also pay attention to how someone moves, how they feel, and how they respond to training.

The numbers are tools. They are not the objective.

And learning to trust your body, to recognize when to push and when to back off, is itself a skill worth developing.

In a case of coincidental timing, Smash just sent me a clip from a brain surgeon that I truly enjoyed.

He summed it up with one powerful quote:

“That’s not optimizing. It’s training fragility.”

Back to Blog